Douglas Krantz - Technical Writer - Describing How It Works
Get the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire Alarms

What is the Difference Between a Fire / Smoke Damper and a Fire Damper

In a building's ventilation system, a fire / smoke damper will close when smoke or high heat is present in the ductwork next to the damper. A fire damper will close only when there is high heat in the duct near the damper.

A motorized fire damper, fire smoke damper, or smoke damper is a damper that is hele open by a motor. If the motor fails to operate, the damper will automatically go to the fire mode.

Hi Douglas,

I'm hoping you can help me better understand what the difference is between an FSD and Fire Damper.

Thank you, R T

The first answer is that a FSD is a Fire/Smoke Damper that closes with either fire or smoke, and the Fire Damper closes only with fire and stays open with smoke. There are similarities and differences between them. Either one can be manually reset or automatically reset (opened).

In essence, it's inside the damper that the detection takes place. A fire damper closes when heat from a fire is detected at the damper, smoke damper closes when smoke is detected inside the air duct at the damper, and a fire / smoke damper closes when either smoke or heat is detected.

Similarities

All air duct dampers are inside air ducts, even short air duct vents between rooms. The length of the air duct may be as short as 4 inches (about 10 centimeters) or as long as hundreds of feet or meters. The dampers are usually located at the fire or smoke walls, used to prevent the spread of fire and smoke.

Because air ducts are openings in the fire walls between fire zones, the air ducts require some way of automatically closing should there be a fire.

Differences

The dampers have physical differences between types. These differences are in the manually resetting type and the automatically resetting type, and in the type of danger - fire and/or smoke - that is detected to close the damper. A curtain damper has a metal curtain that is normally held in the open position by a fusible link. If the fusible link heats up, the curtain closes.

Manually Reset Damper

The manually reset damper is a curtain that drops down to totally block air movement when fire or smoke is detected. The curtain is folded up metal at the top of the damper and held up with a thermal "fuse" (two pieces of metal with calibrated low temperature solder keeping the pieces of metal together).

Even though the curtain type damper is totally inside the air duct, the damper has to be accessible from the outside in order to inspect it and to reset it. The access is either with a removable hatch on the duct, or a removable grate in front of the duct opening.

Fusible thermal links are installed even at the bottom of trash and laundry chutes to prevent fire from getting into the chute and using the chute as a chimney to spread fire from floor to floor. A motorized damper is a damper that is held open by a motor. If the motor fails, the damper automatically closes into fire mode postition.

Motor (Automatic) Reset Damper

Like Venetian Blinds, motorized dampers have louvers. When the louvers are turned one way, they let the air through, and when turned the other way, they block the air. When looking through the inspection access, you can see whether the damper blocks the air or not.

Fire marshals and building inspectors want to have access ports to visually see the louvers on the damper. Even though the turning shaft on the motor is marked to show whether the damper is open or closed, the mechanics inside the damper may slip and the damper may not completely open or may not completely close.

The motor is "powered on" and the damper is spring loaded to close any time the motor stops working. If there is a fire, the motor is turned off and the damper closes. If there is a power outage, the motor is turned off and the damper closes. If there is a fire while there is a power outage, the motor does not need power to close the damper because the damper is already closed. If there is a failure of the system, the damper fails in the closed position - the damper is "Fail-Safe".

Because the motor used to keep the damper open is always turned on, you can put your hand on the motor and feel that it is warm. If the motor is cold, it is not working.

Detectors



Smoke vs Heat

The dampers can be closed with smoke in the air duct, or with heat from a fire in the air duct. In some cases, both a smoke detector and a heat detector installed and either one can close the damper.

Alarm or Supervisory

If the detector is just a thermal link which comes apart when low temperature solder melts, there is no signal to send to the alarm panel. If the solder in the link melts for any reason, the curtain just closes and someone will have to figure out why the air stopped.

Sometime before the turn of the century (the year 2000 is the turn of the century) someone figured out that the air handling equipment isn't always turned on, so air is not always being pushed through the dampers. This means that fire or smoke detection in an air duct can't be relied on to detect fires, so duct detectors (both heat and smoke types) usually aren't considered to be fire alarm devices. Therefore, in most cases, any alarm that they activate has to be supervisory and not fire alarm.

Just as a reminder, a fire alarm and a supervisory alarm are both alarms. A fire alarm turns on a red light on the fire alarm control panel, makes a lot of noise around the building, and usually calls the monitoring company with an alarm. A supervisory, while being a type of alarm, only turns on a yellow light and the local buzzer on the control panel, doesn't make a lot of noise around the building, and calls the monitoring company with a supervisory alarm, not a fire alarm.

Fire Damper (FD)

A fire damper is activated by heat from a fire inside the air duct. The heat can be detected by a fusible link, or by a heat detector in the air duct.

Fusible Link - low temperature solder is holding two pieces of metal together. The solder is designed to melt at a specific temperature. When heat from a fire melts the solder, the two pieces of metal come apart, allowing a smoke curtain to drop.

Mechanical Heat Detector - Often a bimetal strip or conventional fire alarm heat detector is used to interrupt the power to the motor. Some heat detectors will automatically reset, some require the use of a pushbutton on the fire duct detector housing to reset, some require the fire alarm control panel to be reset.

Smoke Damper (SD)

The detector is a smoke detector inside the air duct. It is mounted outside the air duct but using sampling tubes, or an area room smoke detector placed close enough to the vent cover of the air duct to activate with smoke inside the duct.

When the air duct smoke detector activates, it can use an on-board relay to shut off power to the damper motor or use the on-board relay to send a signal to the fire alarm control panel, which then turns off power to the damper motor.

Both Fire and Smoke Damper (FSD)

Both a heat detector and a smoke detector are used to close the damper.

Motor Shut-down - If the damper is automatically reset with a motor, the motor loses power and shuts the damper when either the duct smoke detector or when the duct heat detector is activated with smoke or heat.

Electro-Thermal Link - The link is a thermal fuse with a plus. For the heat detection, there are two pieces of metal held together with low temperature solder (just like the fusible link described earlier) and it has an electrical heater (that's the plus).

If there's heat from a fire, the solder melts. If there's smoke, power is applied to the heater and the heater melts the solder.

A common problem with this is that if there's a false activation of the smoke detector or the duct detector, even if the detector is just being tested to see if it works, the heater melts the solder. Then the electro-fusible link has to be replaced and wired in before the damper can be held open again.

Install, Service, Test

The dampers themselves are usually the responsibility of the HVAC (Heat, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) people to install, and to service. The detectors are usually the responsibility of the fire alarm installers, servicers, and testers because the smoke detectors and some heat detectors are connected to the building's fire alarm control panel.

There is a grey area between what the HVAC people do and what the fire alarm people do. Sometimes the installation, servicing, and testing is totally the responsibility of the HVAC people, sometimes it's totally the responsibility of the fire alarm people, and sometimes the two trades have to work together to install, service, and test the systems.

Words

The bottom line is the damper is in the air duct passing through a smoke wall or fire wall in a building. The damper is used to block the duct. A smoke damper will be closed if smoke is present (SD), a fire damper will be closed if heat from a fire is present (FD), and a smoke/fire damper will be closed if either smoke or heat from a fire is present (FSD).

Douglas Krantz
Based on his electronics training, and his understanding of Life Safety, Douglas Krantz has compiled his knowledge of Conventional Fire Alarm Systems into the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire Alarms. The book covers the basics of the Conventional Fire Alarm System, and shows how Life Safety and internal supervision affects the fire alarm system.

Douglas Krantz -- Fire Alarm Engineering Technician, Electronic Designer, Electronic Technician, Writer

Share This With Friends:

Go to the Fire Alarm Description Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Residential Life Safety Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Residential Life Safety Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Fire Alarm Description Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the General Electrical Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Fire Alarm Maintaining Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Fire Suppression Map Page of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
Go to the Guest Writer's Guidelines of Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
See Trivia on Douglas Krantzs Technicians Corner
This website uses cookies. See Privacy for details.
Get the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire AlarmsGet the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire AlarmsGet the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire AlarmsGet the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire AlarmsGet the book Make It Work - Conventional Fire Alarms
Reader's Favorite Articles

What is a Stair Pressurization Fan (SPF)?

Which Way Does Electricity Flow?

What's the Difference Between Class A and Class B?

What Makes the End of Line Resistor So Important?

What is a Flyback Diode?

What is a Fire Alarm System?

What is an RTU (Roof Top Unit)?

What Causes an Open NAC?

Learn about fire alarms, one article at a time -

Keep up on the latest article!




No Charge - Unsubscribe Anytime